The CorePoint is a deposit training and technology company built and operated by bankers. Innovations created by The CorePoint come from inside the banking industry and strive to address the challenges of change head on. That means we will tell you where the risks are, but it also means we have worked to anticipate all that banking institutions will need to bring Redeemable CDs to market efficiently, compliantly, and with proper risk controls.
Serving markets with deposits comes with inherent risk, Redeemables CDs share those risks, but do not add risks not already managed by institutions. For example, in 2023, financial institutions had penalties of 90-days of interest that – during a rising rate environment – resulted in minuscule early withdrawal penalties relative to the interest depositors could earn by "refinancing" their CD elsewhere. The traditional CD structure carried a risk that many institutions did not manage, instead they maintained a static and arbitrary penalty, even when it risked lost profits on deposits.
Redeemable CD is a process that allows financial institutions to customize early withdrawal. It carries the same "risk" as outlined in the above example from 2023: The institution might price early withdrawal in ways not beneficial to profitability. That said, adopting Redeemable CD aligns with efforts to improve how early withdrawal risk is managed. It's an enhancement to funding management relative to time-old banking practice.
Balance sheet managers are wise to consider how a new servicing option, such as personalized early withdrawal, would affect their funding.
As in the example covered in the prior question, early withdrawal pricing in 2023 – the static penalty of 30- or 90-days interest – was incentivizing CD refinancing. The cost of early withdrawal was too low. When using the Redeemable CD process, the banking institution sets early withdrawal cost (the penalty amount) by benchmarking its replacement cost to wholesale funding costs.
Here's an example of how that works: Consider a depositor with 12 months remaining on a CD at 5.2% with a current balance of $100,000. If the CD reaches maturity, it will cost the institution $5,200. If wholesale rates are now at 4.2%, and the depositor withdraws early, the total possible benefit to your institution is about $1,000 because you can replace the funding at 4.2%.
The balance sheet becomes more protected because the institution can incentivize (or not incentivize) early withdrawal. The withdrawal cast (the penalty) to the depositor is always tied to the damage or benefit of the early withdrawal.
Four charters have utilized the Redeemable CD process and passed state and federal regulatory exams.
Institutions that partner with us to allow early withdrawal by converting existing (traditional) CDs into Redeemable CDs, as well as those that partner to originate Redeemable CDs, will receive the needed compliance language and training.
Whether using the Redeemable CD process to originate CDs with an exit option or to enhance traditional CDs by offering early withdrawal when advantageous, an institution can decide how far it takes the process digitally.
The CorePoint provides clients with the training and tools to service CD holders wanting to redeem (early withdrawal) funds. Staff and depositors can use a simple calculator, which you can test here. When launched in this way, Redeemable CDs do not require any software development from a core because they are not structurally different than any other CD on the core systems.
One step an institution would likely take in their core would be to add a new set of CDs – not dissimilar from adding a new series of traditional CD offerings – so that it can originate and track which CDs are traditional and which were originated for a depositor expecting the ability to redeem early.
It's common for institutions to have accounts that are not marketed to the general deposit base or marketplace. We see this among clients with our limited edition savings account, which they only use in a scenario where they either match a competitor or lose the account.
An attainable place to start for Redeemable CDs is to engage only the segment of your deposit portfolio for which early withdrawal is mutually beneficial about the option to withdraw. An example is a depositor with 12 months remaining on a CD at 5.2% with a current balance of $100,000. If the CD reaches maturity, the interest expense to the institution will be $5,200. Suppose the depositor needs the funds, and wholesale rates are now at 4.2%. If the depositor withdraws early, the total possible benefit to your institution is about $1,000 because you can replace the funding at 4.2%.
The institution could start by adopting the Redeemable CD process with a select few CD holders when it is advantageous. It could be done via digital banking, email, or through interactions with staff. The identifier would be CD holders with a rate that creates a sufficient gain (as defined by your institution).
When engaging traditional CD users, you would use digital banking, email, or through interactions with staff to make the option known: Returns on withdrawal are always the same or better than the traditional CD.
When originating Redeemable CDs, a picture is more helpful than text. Here is a comparison that clarifies how Redeemables compare and who they are for.
We have also created three marketing email examples to illustrate how your messaging might look, and who it would be for. Vew those messages here.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.